Sapphire Engagement Rings vs Diamond Engagement Rings | With Clarity (2024)

Engagement rings are a big, life-long decision, and with all of the different options offered, picking just one ring can be overwhelming. Traditionally, engagement rings have been diamonds, diamonds, diamonds, but as of late, other gemstones have begun to gain popularity within the engagement ring community. People nowadays may sport a little color on their left hand, given by anemerald, ruby, or sapphire. Sapphires, especially, have surged in popularity as Princess Kate Middleton wears an 18-carat royal blue sapphire previously belonging to Princess Diana.

Betweenyellow gold, white gold, rose gold, and platinum, the choices already seem endless, but with the addition of the choice between sapphire or diamond, the options grow exponentially. While there are plenty of different engagement ring options, there is no “right” or “wrong” ring. Each engagement ring style depends solely on the preferences of the couple purchasing it. Sapphire and diamond differences are few but significant. Picking between these two stones can change the engagement ring immensely.


Price Advantages of Diamond and Sapphire Rings Sapphire Engagement Ring Styles

Although not as popular asdiamonds, thesapphire has become a more typical stone for an engagement ring. Rightfully so, as sapphires can add that “something blue” to any wedding. Additionally, the legends of sapphires make them increasingly more desirable. In ancient times, sapphires were said to have medicinal and protective powers, while in medieval times, they were said to be symbolic of honesty and wisdom. During these times, sapphire was a typical gemstone for royalty given its royal blue color and its lucky powers. Today, however, a sapphire engagement ring is loved for its rich color and durability.

Sapphire Engagement Rings Pros & Cons

Sapphire pros include its durability and hardness, earning a 9 on the Mohs scale. However, diamond pros also include hardness, ranking at a 10, the highest for any natural stone found on Earth. The high level of hardness makes both sapphires and diamond engagement rings a logical choice for everyday use. The durability debate does not end here though because sapphires can more easily be scratched, a rarity for diamonds. Sapphire cons include the necessity to take the stone in for extra care such as re-polishing and re-cutting. Although it is more damage-prone than a diamond, the high sapphire durability makes it a more popular choice than other gemstones, such as emeralds or rubies.

Diamonds refract more light than sapphires do, appearing more brilliant, adding to their value. While a diamond is valued for its brilliance, sapphire value is determined by its diamonds and thecolor. Sapphires are made up of the element corundum, but trace amounts of other elements give them especially vivid colors. Blue sapphires, the most popular choice, contain iron and titanium, while white sapphires are made up of pure corundum, making the stone colorless. The blue sapphire remains the most valuable because it is also the rarest type of sapphire. It’s most important quality is the richness of the color; a perfect sapphire will be a deep blue without any other modifying colors. Although less popular, sapphires can also be found in pink, purple, orange, yellow, green, and black. Uniquely, one of the pros of buying a sapphire is that there is a stone for every skin tone. Lighter skin will be complemented by a sapphire containing pastel undertones, darker skin will be complemented by cobalt undertones, and olive skin will be complemented by a royal blue sapphire.

Diamonds sparkle even when they are dirty, but a white sapphire may not. Therefore, if the color is what piques your interest, sapphire is the right choice, but if clear is your desire, diamond is the way to go. No two sapphires are exactly alike. A sapphire engagement ring is guaranteed to be unique, making sapphires more intimate than diamonds. Because of their uniqueness, durability, and intense color, sapphires are quickly becoming more popular in engagement rings, triggering a quick rise in value. Regardless, sapphires remain to be less valuable than diamonds, allowing for engagement rings to have a bigger sapphire at a lower cost. For example, the standard size for sapphire is about 6 mm which equates to a .75 carat diamond in cost.

Price Advantages of Diamond and Sapphire Rings

Choosing engagement rings with diamonds and sapphires can save you bundles of money. While both diamonds and sapphires are rare and precious, buying jewelry with a combination of the gems can reduce the amount you would spend on multi-stone rings with just one or the other.

For example, if you chose an engagement ring with an excellent-grade center diamond, you’d have to ensure that any other diamonds in that ring were equally brilliant and clear, or it would be drastically noticeable. Although sapphires are graded just as diamonds or any other gemstone, a sapphire that was strong in color, but a little cloudy or with an extra inclusion or two, wouldn’t be apparent to the casual observer, especially with such a radiantly sparkling center diamond. It would also save you money because you aren’t buying an ALL top-grade diamond or sapphire engagement ring.

Sapphire Engagement Ring Styles

Populardiamond engagement ring styles include the Solitaire and the Halo, but as the ring grows more complex, the value skyrockets. However, the cut of sapphire is not as important as the cut of a diamond because overall, it is harder to see inclusions of a sapphire with the naked eye. Popularly, sapphire rings can have round, oval, and cushion shapes. The oval cut sapphire gives the engagement ring a more vintage and nostalgic look, while the round is more timeless. Often, sapphire engagement rings have diamond accents or engraving details. One of the most popular choices for a colorful ring is the three stone sapphire engagement ring. This particular ring offers a center sapphire flanked by two smaller diamonds. Another popular choice is a sapphire halo diamond ring that features diamonds encircling the entire sapphire gem.

Sapphires and diamonds balance out in their pros and cons, but ultimately, diamonds are more traditional. However, sapphires are always an option for couples wanting to take have an engagement ring that truly stands out.

White gold bands are a popular choice for engagement rings with both diamonds and sapphires. Some people prefer the simple white gold band, while others choose designs that incorporate accent diamonds or sapphires over a part, or all, of the band. Platinum is also another common choice, because it’s another white metal, and it’s durable and strong.

Some gemstone cuts for diamond and sapphire engagement rings include round, oval, princess and cushion cut stones. People even often pair round with oval gems or cushion with emerald cut diamonds and sapphires. Both of these stones work well for center stones and provide a timeless complement to one another when paired with accent stones. They also work well in tri-stone styles.

A popular style for engagement rings with sapphires is vintage. Sapphires make excellent antique looking rings, especially in halo settings, or surrounded by filigree (beaded) metal work.


Should I buy a sapphire engagement ring?

Yes, a sapphire engagement ring adds "something blue" to an engagement ring and is an excellent alternative to the diamond. With a rating of 9 on Moh's hardness scale and a mesmerizing hue, it can be worn as a beautiful symbol of your love without the stress of damage.

Are sapphires only blue in color?

No, sapphires are also found in other shades, such as pink, purple, orange, yellow, green, and black.

Which is the best style for a sapphire engagement ring?

This would depend on the wearer's style and your budget. However, solitaire and a halo are some of the most popular styles. You could opt for a round, oval, or cushion-cut sapphire with diamond accents for an engagement ring that is classy yet unique.

What is the best metal for a sapphire engagement ring?

White gold is an excellent metal choice for sapphire engagement rings as this metal infuses the piece with timeless sophistication. Platinum is another excellent choice that is hypoallergenic and durable, with a patina finish that will look great even years later.

Is a diamond engagement ring better than a sapphire engagement ring?

While a diamond is a foolproof and elegant choice for an engagement ring, sapphire is a great way to showcase luxury and vibrancy. You can even opt for a sapphire ring accented with diamonds to get the best of both stones.

As an enthusiast and expert in gemstones and engagement rings, my extensive knowledge in the field allows me to provide valuable insights into the choices and considerations surrounding this significant life-long decision. Having delved deep into the world of gemstones, including diamonds and sapphires, I can offer a nuanced perspective on the various factors influencing the selection of an engagement ring.

Diamonds vs. Sapphires: A Comprehensive Comparison

1. Historical Significance and Popularity:

  • Diamonds have long been the traditional choice for engagement rings. The enduring popularity of diamonds is deeply ingrained in cultural traditions.
  • In recent times, there's a notable shift, with other gemstones like sapphires gaining prominence. Princess Kate Middleton's 18-carat royal blue sapphire, formerly Princess Diana's, has played a role in this shift.

2. Sapphire Symbolism and Appeal:

  • Sapphires offer a unique appeal by adding a touch of color to the left hand, with options like emerald, ruby, or sapphire itself.
  • Historical beliefs in the medicinal and protective powers of sapphires, along with symbolic associations with honesty and wisdom, contribute to their allure.

3. Sapphire Durability and Characteristics:

  • Sapphires score a 9 on the Mohs scale of hardness, making them durable for everyday use. However, diamonds, with a perfect score of 10, are slightly harder.
  • While sapphires may be more prone to scratching, their durability and rich color, especially in blue sapphires, make them a popular choice.

4. Value Determinants:

  • Diamonds are valued for their brilliance, which results from their ability to refract more light than sapphires.
  • Sapphires derive value from their color, with blue sapphires being particularly prized. The rarity and intensity of color are crucial factors in determining a sapphire's value.

5. Color Variety and Complementing Skin Tones:

  • Sapphires come in various colors, allowing for a personalized choice that complements different skin tones.
  • The uniqueness of each sapphire contributes to the individuality of the engagement ring, offering a distinct advantage over diamonds.

6. Cost Considerations:

  • Sapphires, while less valuable than diamonds, allow for larger stones at a lower cost. This affordability is a significant factor for couples considering a bigger gemstone.

7. Style Choices and Setting:

  • Engagement ring styles vary, with both diamonds and sapphires featuring prominently. Popular styles include solitaire, halo, and vintage designs.
  • The choice between white gold and platinum for the band, as well as different gemstone cuts, adds further customization options.

8. Practical Considerations:

  • Sapphires may require additional care, such as re-polishing and re-cutting, due to their susceptibility to scratches.
  • The choice between a sapphire and a diamond may depend on personal preferences, with sapphires appealing to those who prioritize color over clarity.

Conclusion: In the realm of engagement rings, the decision between a diamond and a sapphire involves a careful consideration of personal preferences, historical significance, symbolism, durability, and budget constraints. While diamonds maintain their timeless elegance, sapphires offer a vibrant and unique alternative, presenting couples with a plethora of choices to symbolize their love.

Sapphire Engagement Rings vs Diamond Engagement Rings | With Clarity (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Barbera Armstrong

Last Updated:

Views: 5528

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (79 voted)

Reviews: 94% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Barbera Armstrong

Birthday: 1992-09-12

Address: Suite 993 99852 Daugherty Causeway, Ritchiehaven, VT 49630

Phone: +5026838435397

Job: National Engineer

Hobby: Listening to music, Board games, Photography, Ice skating, LARPing, Kite flying, Rugby

Introduction: My name is Barbera Armstrong, I am a lovely, delightful, cooperative, funny, enchanting, vivacious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.